Friday, November 20, 2026

The Pointy End

 I almost missed the story from earlier this week that our secretaries of state and defense have apparently endorsed the idea that laws don't apply to anyone powerful and violent enough to disregard them. This episode began when Little Marco, flopping around in Daddy's shoes, said apropos of the International Criminal Court that one should not "quote laws to men with swords." I wasn't there, but one suspects his adolescent voice cracked and squeaked slightly as he said it. 

Pete Hegseth then apparently re-tweeted the remark with even less context, but far greater passion and enthusiasm. "Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS," he said—with the all caps included. One suspects our Secretary of Defense was barely thinking about the ICC at this point, and really just liked the way the image evoked something dangling between one's legs. One senses in much that this SecDef says, after all, a world-historical exercise in compensation. 

Indeed, it's impossible to write about this administration's "might makes right" foreign policy for any length of time before the phallic metaphors start coming at us fast and hard. Someone will inevitably mention Teddy Roosevelt's "big stick." A writer in The New Republic observes that Rubio and Hegseth both appear to embrace the proposition that power flows from "the barrel of a gun or the pointy end of a Tomahawk cruise missile." 

Indeed, both secretaries can't seem to stop telling us about their "pointy ends" (or the ones they wish they had). "We're men with swords!" they shout to all and sundry. One is reminded keenly of Harold Pinter's immortal poem, written on the eve of the U.S. invasion of Iraq: "There's no escape. / The big pricks are out. / They'll fuck everything in sight. / Watch your back." Two decades later, Pinter's analysis of the psychic roots of U.S. foreign policy has never been improved upon. 

Not all Republicans are impressed with this administration's embrace of the Hobbesian law of the jungle as the guiding principle of our foreign policy. The New York Times yesterday quoted one anti-Trump former GOP representative on the subject: "Declaring that laws become irrelevant the moment swords appear is [...] just 'might makes right,' which is a fundamental rejection of both Christian ethics and America’s founding."

As the New Republic author concurs: this proposition also has nothing to do with the traditional tenets of U.S. foreign policy or our long-cherished understanding of what the role of the State Department or the Pentagon should be. As she puts it well: "The fact that the U.S. secretaries of state and defense ascribe to this 'might makes right' stance [... and its] amoral and sophomoric attitude of 'Good. Bad. I’m the guy with the gun' also runs contrary to the most basic tenets of their jobs."

But to the extent our government really has embraced the principle of "Freedom no more, but Might, and Might alone!" (to quote one of Ernest Crosby's anti-imperialist poems)— to the extent, that is, that our foreign policy now conforms to what Wordsworth called "the simple plan / That they should take, who have the power, / And they should keep who can" (See "Rob Roy's Grave")—to that extent, indeed, they have come in for a rude surprise. 

After all, "might" doesn't appear to be working out very well for them. The "men with swords" don't seem to be wielding them very effectively. Iran more or less fought them to a standstill, and by means of a few measly drones managed to reverse their nationwide electoral fortunes by raising gas prices. And under their own stated principles, this administration has no right to complain. If laws don't matter, and only men with swords decide by means of their pointy ends, then sucks to be them. 

I am reminded again of Anatole France's words in The White Stone (Roche trans.). One of his characters in the novel issues a prescient warning about Teddy Roosevelt's "might makes right" doctrines and all his "big stick" braggadocio. As he sums up TR's foreign policy thinking: "'Fight, my friends,' says Mr. Roosevelt, 'and fight hard. There is nothing like blows. We are upon earth only to exterminate one another.'" 

But, France likewise observes, "we witness a strange whirligig of things, and brute force, up to now the sole judge of human actions, indulges occasionally in unexpected pranks." If you really do think that brute force is all that matters—if you really do think that "the real world," as Stephen Miller has put it, is governed only by "strength, force, and power"— then you lose the right to complain if the law of brute force turns against you, and you fail in a straight fight. Which in this case, they did. 

I think here of D.H. Lawrence's ever-timely warning: "They say: [...] Post me, nihil— But perhaps, my dears, / nihil will come along and hit you on the head." 

No comments:

Post a Comment