Monday, November 16, 2026

Nobody's Missing

 The other day at a used book store, I picked up an old copy of an almost entirely forgotten Paul Theroux thriller, Chicago Loop (1990). Like many readers, I knew Theroux primarily through his nonfiction travel writing (and his parentage of the ever-hilarious and disarming Louis Theroux), so I was curious to see what I would make of one of his novels. 

I was not exactly thrilled. The novel has the— distinction, I guess?—of being an early addition to the "Yuppie psychopath" sub-genre of American fiction (it precedes American Psycho by a year), and it reminds one more than anything of that bizarre Nicholas Cage movie, Vampire's Kiss, with elements of 1980's Dressed to Kill. 

Indeed, it reads at times as if it were mostly written with one eye on the hopes of getting optioned for some Brian De Palma film adaptation that never came to be. 

Both the movie version of American Psycho and the Cage performance in Vampire's Kiss, though, are wise enough to lean into camp and satire, and one feels this book could have benefited from more of the same. Theroux appears, by contrast, to want us to take this seriously, which is rather difficult. The book's psycho-sexual premise is too melodramatic and implausible. 

Our protagonist, Parker, is a real estate bro and Country Club Yuppie by day who lives in tony Evanston, north of downtown Chicago. By night, however, he is a sexual predator (so far, at least, this part of the premise cannot really strike us as implausible—not in the era of our post-#MeToo, post-Epstein, post-Alexander brothers reckoning). 

Where things begin to stretch the suspension of disbelief, however, is when Parker starts wandering around worrying that he may have killed someone the other night—in a sado-masochistic sexual frenzy—but now he simply cannot remember whether he did so or not. "[S]urely he had imagined it," he thinks to himself; "Perhaps he had just wished it into his mind." 

I'm reminded of a story Kaelyn Moore told on a recent episode of her podcast about a friend of hers who suffered from obsessive-compulsive neurosis. One of their compulsive mental loops took the form of worrying that they may have accidentally hit someone while driving without realizing it. Eventually, this obsession became so severe that they started retracing their commute multiple times every morning to check for unknown victims. 

Weirdly, I can totally relate to this fear. But Moore makes the reassuring point that if you really did hit someone with your car, you would know. "It wouldn't be a secret," as she put it.  

One is inclined to say the same to Parker: Bro, if you really did tear someone's throat out in the heat of sexual psychosis the other night, I think you would remember. 

If we are meant to treat this not as something that literally happened in the plot, however, but as a paranoid delusion in Parker's mind that reflects some feeling of directionless internal guilt, it starts to take on more psychological plausibility. 

I'm reminded of that haunting and indelible poem by John Berryman, from his Dream Songs, which describes a desperate internal moral account-keeping that sounds very similar to Moore's friend obsessively retracing their morning drive every day, to make sure they haven't accidentally left forgotten corpses behind, or Parker worrying that he might be a secret murderer: 

never did Henry, as he thought he did,

end anyone and hacks her body up

and hide the pieces, where they may be found.

He knows: he went over everyone, & nobody’s missing.   

Often he reckons, in the dawn, them up.

Nobody is ever missing.

Suppose we take Parker's "forgotten" role as a murderer as a metaphor, then—a metaphor for what? Perhaps, for some subconscious guilt about the way he has exploited and hurt women in his career as a "womanizer," as it once would have been called.  

On this theory, Parker's feelings about his "murder victim," Sharon, are just a distillation of his guilt about countless other people he has harmed through selfishness. He attends her funeral in one scene, and realizes that "she belonged to a world he had known nothing about," Theroux writes; "And it made Parker feel that he had interfered with that world, that he has upset the balance of it[.]"

I am reminded of Philip Larkin's line about the hedgehog he accidentally caught in his lawn mower: "I had mauled its unobtrusive world / Unmendably." 

Unlike hitting someone with your car without realizing it, or accidentally murdering someone in a fit of sexual passion, killing a hedgehog or other innocent rodent with your lawn mower is unfortunately an all too realistic possibility. And, here as elsewhere, Larkin's words have a power that extends beyond their immediate context, to name some more generalized dread. 

That dread—the same guilt that haunts Henry in Berryman's poem—does not have to be interpreted as some memory of actual violence or criminality. It might just be a guilty recollection of the way we all hurt others at times through accident or indifference—through selfishly pursuing our projects, to which other people's lives and feelings become so much collateral damage. 

As Schopenhauer observes in his essay On the Basis of Morality, most of the harm we inflict on others in this world stems not from malice or sadism, but from egoism. We are simply unaware of the impact of what we do on others, and their "unobtrusive worlds."

As Schopenhauer puts it: "It is true that Egoism may lead to wickedness and crime of every sort; but the resulting injury and pain to others are simply the means, not the end, and are therefore involved only as an accident." (Bullock trans.)

If we take Theroux's Chicago Loop not as an account of a literal crime, then, but as a psychological metaphor for the guilt that stems from someone realizing the havoc they have wrought in other people's lives through selfish behavior, it becomes a much more poignant novel—particularly as the protagonist goes on to pursue his unique self-mortifying form of penance. 

Read in this spirit, the novel deserves to be revisited—particularly in a cultural moment like our own, when we are all having to reckon daily, every time we read the news, with the effects of unchecked masculine narcissism and sexual aggression. 

No comments:

Post a Comment