One of the odd twists of this midterm election cycle is that even in the context of overwhelming Democratic victories and a clear electoral shift to the left, a number of right-wing ballot initiatives nonetheless passed at the state level. Several of these had to do with forcing transgender student athletes to compete (if at all) on teams that align with their assigned sex at birth.
A friend was pointing out to me the other day that this is the sort of culture war issue where people's opinions can swing wildly as soon as we frame the question not as: "what do you want to happen?" but rather: "how will this rule be enforced in practice?"
It's like abortion. If you ask most people: is abortion a good thing?, most sane people will say: no, it's clearly a bad thing. But if you ask: okay, so, should the government ban women from receiving them? If so, how? Should there be criminal penalties? Civil? On doctors? On mothers? Suddenly, at that point, most people say: no, it should obviously be legal, albeit (hopefully) rare.
So too, apparently many people have a strong intuition that athletes should only be allowed to compete on teams that align with their assigned "biological" sex, and that anything else is unfair.
I do not share this intuition myself. Largely because I don't care about sports anyway, and it's hard for me to understand those who do. But this appears to be something that many other people in society feel very strongly about.
And because of this intuition, many ordinary voters look at ballot initiatives like the ones in Colorado and Arizona, and they say: "well, do I think boys should be playing on girls teams? No I don't. So I'm in favor of this measure."
But suppose, as with abortion, we frame the question not as: "do you want this thing to happen in an ideal world", but rather: "what do you want to allow the government to do to enforce this ban?" How, in this case, should state governments be deciding who is a "boy" and who is a "girl" for purposes of implementing the new rule? By DNA tests? By genital exams?
This is the point at which I think the vast majority of people—except for the extreme religious right—would suddenly change their minds. They would think: wait a minute, determining someone's "biological sex" is just not really the government's business. It's invasive and freaky. They shouldn't be looking into that in the first place.
Most Americans basically agree with A.E. Housman on the topic of government coercion: "if my ways are not as theirs/ let them mind their own affairs." Live and let live, in short. It's only right-wing extremists who "must still / Wrest their neighbor to their will, / And make me dance as they desire / With jail and gallows and hell-fire."
No comments:
Post a Comment