Friday, October 2, 2026

Nightmare Scene

 In his Reflections on the Guillotine, Albert Camus argues that every government that wants to maintain the death penalty should have to conduct all of their executions in public. Indeed, they should broadcast footage of the state murder as widely as possible. 

He argues this because, in the absence of it, the public has no window into what actually happens in the death chamber. This allows the authorities to draw a veil of decorum over the whole hideous proceeding. As Arthur Koestler observes, in his Reflections on Hanging, the officials and the newspapers can talk about the execution in somber tones afterwards, leaving us to believe that all was transacted with the utmost calm and respect. 

This allows us to blissfully ignore the fact, as he writes, that "some prisoners struggle both in the condemned cell and under the noose, that some have to be carried tied to a chair, others dragged to the trap, limp, bowels open [...] and that still other things happen which should only happen in nightmare dreams." He cites as one example "the case of a sick woman of twenty-eight whose insides fell out before she vanished through the trap." 

I have wondered ever since reading Koestler's book if Hugh MacDiarmid had that same incident in mind, when he wrote in one of his poems about: The hypocrisy, falsity, and callousness of the Law, / The infernal sadism that hauls to the scaffold a poor woman sick at both ends...

Governments hypocritically pretend that they do not show us these things in public out of some respect for the "dignity" of the condemned. Absurd. The real reason, Camus writes, is that they are ashamed on some level of their own methods. They know that they are transgressing some primal law by taking the life by force of a person who is helpless. They know that capital punishment violates what he calls "the only indisputable human solidarity—our solidarity against death[.]"

They don't want to show us the executions because the footage would remind us of these facts. We would see the "nightmare scenes" that our own policies of lethal execution and nitrogen gas and electrocution and the firing squad inevitably entail. 

But if authorities are indeed generally able to draw an impenetrable veil over these proceedings—the horrific botched execution of Christa Pike yesterday in Tennessee managed to pierce it. In the accounts of the unsuccessful repeated attempts to end her life by force, the public got a glimpse into one of those "nightmare scenes" Koestler described—the ones the government is generally at pains to hide, or—at most—to disclose only through the most polite and neutral newspaper prose.

Indeed, for Christa Pike, it was indeed the waking enactment of a "nightmare dream" in the worst and fullest sense. As the New York Times reports, quoting one of Pike's attorneys: "It fulfilled Ms. Pike’s greatest fear, he said, which was 'a fear of a prolonged, painful, traumatic death.' 'And that’s what happened,' Mr. Ferrell said. 'Minus the death.'"

Let us not let go of that image. That is what the death penalty really means. That is what states are doing all over this country to ten or more people every year. That is the "infernal sadism" we are inflicting on the instructions of state legislatures and judges who feel that killing defenseless prisoners, who have been incapacitated and laid at their mercy, is just and necessary, but who don't want to share photos and videos of what they are doing, lest we witness how ugly the scene really is.

Hypocrisy, falsity, and callousness indeed!

No comments:

Post a Comment