Monday, October 5, 2026

"It Doesn't Really Hurt"

 Up there with the notion that "everyone goes to the death chamber with great dignity and decorum," another great myth about capital punishment is that the state can somehow murder people "humanely."

As Arthur Koestler writes in his classic Reflections on Hanging, "the defense of a savage method of execution on the grounds that 'it doesn't really hurt,' is another leitmotif down to our day."

Today, that same leitmotif takes the form of the belief that lethal injection is a relatively "painless" method of execution. In truth, there is no such thing—as we saw yet again this week in Tennessee. 

The horrific failed execution of Christa Pike just days ago—which left her intubated in a hospital with chemical burns up and down her arm—laid this fact searingly before the public. 

As Dr. Joel Zivot writes in yesterday's New York Times, this case should remind us that death row prisoners have essentially no guarantee lethal injection will be as "painless" as claimed. 

We have basically no way of knowing how states obtain or concoct the fatal mixture, since many pharmaceutical companies (rightly) refuse to supply it on ethical grounds. 

Zivot observes: "Tennessee, like other death penalty states, does not disclose how it buys and prepares" the Pentobarbital substance alleged to induce unconsciousness during execution. 

He adds: "This is a state whose own independent review found that none of the drugs prepared for the seven people it executed between 2018 and 2022 had been fully tested."

He therefore says that for all the talk of lethal injection as the "humane" alternative to other methods of ending a person's life by force, many prisoners in fact dread it the most. 

He describes cases in which death row prisoners have requested death by electrocution instead. Christa Pike herself apparently said she would rather be hanged. 

Surely in that fact alone is revealed all / The hypocrisy, falsity, and callousness of the Law, / The infernal sadism that hauls to the scaffold / A poor woman... (Hugh MacDiarmid). 

No one is excusing or minimizing Pike's horrific crime. But surely we can agree that she, like any other human being, has "A neck God made for other use / Than strangling in a string" (Housman).

"The deeper question is whether a state that executes its citizens is willing to look at what it is doing," Zivot concludes his essay; "Lethal injection was designed so that it would not have to."

I am reminded here again of Albert Camus's argument (in Reflections on the Guillotine) that if any government really believed in the validity of capital punishment, it would still conduct these killings in public squares, rather than behind closed doors. 

Earlier this year, a federal judge observed in one capital case that "human life cannot be purposefully extinguished without some risk of pain."

This is undoubtedly true. My answer would be: "then stop purposely extinguishing human life" against a person's will—and not only because it is painful, but because, as Camus wrote, it is a violation of our human "solidarity against death." 

But if voters and judges and politicians and presidents insist on their annual supply of victims to the archaic sacrifice anyway, then they ought at least to pull back the curtain on what they were doing. 

Don't hide behind the pretense of a "painless" death they do not actually provide. 

Let the world see what the state is actually doing in our name. Behold the prisoners writhing in agony. 

See what happened to Christa Pike!

Who then would dare to repeat that same old "leitmotif": "It doesn't really hurt"? 

No comments:

Post a Comment