Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Acte Gratuit

 I spent a lot of time last month, as part of the reflections around the 25th anniversary of 9/11, trying to pinpoint exactly what the difference was between the Bush and Trump administrations. 

After all, every Trump-era human rights abuse has its rough analogue from the Bush and Obama–led War on Terror. 

Trump is incinerating Trinidadian and Venezuelan fishermen in extrajudicial killings. But then, Obama had his drone strikes. 

Trump started a war of aggression in the Middle East. So did Bush. 

Trump is carrying out secret abductions and deportations to third countries where the government knows people will be held without trial and tortured and maltreated. So did Bush. 

Yet, one nonetheless knows exactly what Matt Yglesias means when he said last month (as part of his own 9/11 anniversary reflections) that there is a profound qualitative difference between these two presidencies. 

Bush, for all his flaws, had some sort of continuity with the project of twentieth century liberalism and cosmopolitan universalism, as Yglesias puts it; he believed in the beneficent use of American power around the world. 

Whereas Trump seems to like using American power as much or more than any other president—he just appears to think we're suckers if we use it for anything other than the most crassly materialistic and self-centered ends. 

Bush created PEPFAR; where Trump's regime fed the entirety of USAID "into the wood chipper." Perhaps that tells us all we need to know about the difference between the two presidencies. 

There's obviously much truth, then, to the distinction Yglesias draws. But the angry anti-Bush teenager in me still think it's been overstated. 

The U.S. government was not really as interested in promoting "democracy" during the Bush years as has been claimed. If it were, why did it work with so many authoritarian regimes as partners in the War on Terror? Why did it render people to torture prisons and black sites? 

No, Bush's human rights violations were extreme enough that I can't just chalk them up to excessive zeal in defense of liberal cosmopolitanism. The difference between him and Trump must lie somewhere else. 

I was reading Dwight Macdonald's essay collection The Responsibility of Peoples the other day, and I find him grappling with essentially the same problem in the title essay. 

Macdonald was trying to put his finger on exactly the qualitative difference that separated the two sides fighting in Europe during World War II. 

Macdonald was perhaps the fiercest critic of Allied war crimes against civilian populations of any intellectual of the period. He rightly denounced the firebombing of German and Japanese cities, the mass internment of Japanese American citizens, the U.S. government's close-handed approach to European refugees and displaced persons, and the explosion of atomic bombs over Hiroshima and Nagasaki. 

Yet, even Macdonald was perfectly aware, as evidence of the Holocaust and other Nazi atrocities came to light, that some sort of unbridgeable moral chasm separated the crimes committed by the democratic countries and those committed by the fascist ones. Yet, since both killed civilians and committed war crimes, in what exactly did this difference consist? 

Eventually, he concludes, it lies mostly in "what might be called the 'gratuitous' character of the worst atrocities" committed by the fascists. "What has been done by other peoples as an unpleasant by-product of the attainment of certain ends has been done by the Germans [...] as an end in itself. What has been done elsewhere in violation of the doer's code of ethics, and hence in a shame-faced way draped over with hypocritical apologies, has been done here in conformance with the avowed Nazi moral code[.]"

This too seems to get at the heart of the difference between the Bush- and the Trump-era war crimes. 

I cited in an earlier post the example of Donald Rumsfeld's apology to Congress after the abuses at Abu Ghraib came to light. Maybe those apologies were "hypocritical," in the way Macdonald says. Maybe Rumsfeld's own policies set the conditions for those abuses. Nevertheless, it is telling that the Bush White House felt the need to disavow these atrocities, at least in public. 

It is very difficult to imagine the Trump administration acting similarly under the same circumstances. They have not felt any obligation to apologize to the press and Congress about the men now being hooded and beaten in a secret prison in Equatorial Guinea on their orders. 

And when Trump sent 200 Venezuelan asylum-seekers—people who had been driving Ubers and delivering pizzas in American neighborhoods just days before—to a torture prison in El Salvador, where the public watched them forcibly shaved and bent double by their captors, the administration didn't apologize for it—they celebrated and crowed about it on social media, and Kristi Noem went to film herself gloating over their degradation.

Moreover, everything the Bush administration did could plausibly be interpreted as excesses committed in pursuit of a real enemy that did actually pose a threat to the United States: namely, Al Qaeda. Whereas the Trump administration has revived every worst human rights atrocity of the Bush years without waiting for any external enemy to come along. 

Of course, the administration has tried to magic various enemies into being—the "enemy within," represented by dissidents and liberals, "antifa terrorists," "Tren de Aragua," and various other figments—but everyone can see that the administration is conjuring enemies in order to justify the crimes it wants to commit, rather than committing crimes in pursuit of real-life enemies. 

So too, for every Allied war crime committed in Europe and Japan, Macdonald writes, "there was at least this much humane rationality about it: that it was thought necessary for the winning of the war." We can say the same of the Bush administration—they seemed to think their abuses would actually help protect the nation from terrorism. 

Whereas the rulers of democratic countries may be accused of have placed too little value on human life, Macdonald writes, "the Nazis have not disregarded human life. They have, on the contrary, [...] taken it for the pure, disinterested pleasure of taking it. There was no ulterior motive [...] no possible advantage to its creators beyond the gratification of neurotic racial hatreds. What has previously been done only by individual psychopathic killers has now been done by the rulers and servants of a great modern State. That is something new."

This, truly, is the only real and final difference between the Bush and the Trump administrations. And we can see that it is indeed a meaningful one. 

The Trump administration disappears Afghan and Iranian refugees to the Central African Republic; it sends Cuban refugees to a secret prison in Eswatini, it incinerates hundreds of fishermen in strikes on boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific, it topples the government of another country and then crows about stealing their oil ("to the victor belong the spoils," as Trump recently said in front of the UN). 

They dismantled life-saving international aid programs overnight, causing the likely deaths of hundreds of thousands if not millions of the world's poorest people—many of them children dying of hunger and preventable diseases. And all seemingly for nothing; on a lark; "for idleness," to quote a character from Chekhov's The Seagull. 

It is indeed the "gratuitous" character of these atrocities that strikes one as so fundamentally different from the crimes of the Bush administration. It is the fact that no one can or even pretends to plead a rational end behind any of them. They are staged purely in the name of violence and spectacle and depravity and cruelty for their own sakes. To gratify the "neurotic racial hatreds" of the administration's neo-Nazi fans on social media. Or for the "pure, disinterested pleasure" of causing pain and suffering to others. 

"It may be said, justly," Macdonald adds, "that it makes little difference to the dead kulak or to the dead Jew what the motives of his executioners were." 

So too, it may make little difference to a person rendered to a black site torture dungeon under Bush or Trump whether they met this fate because their tormentors thought they were "fighting terrorism" or merely because they get off on it. 

"But it makes a great deal of difference to the executioners," Macdonald concludes, "and to our evaluation of their act." 

And that is perhaps all that need be said here. When future generations try to sort out who is most worthy of execration among our contemporaries, Bush may at least claim some mitigation for his crimes from the fact that the nation had just been traumatized by 9/11 and he was sincerely committed to fighting a real national security threat. Trump can plead no such excuse. 

And this does indeed make a great deal of difference to our evaluations of their respective administrations.

Of Bush, one can say that a life-saving program like PEPFAR left a real positive legacy in the world. 

Of Trump, and all his kindred gratuitous butchers, by contrast, one can only say that they have effectively exiled themselves from the human race. All we can henceforth do with them is to "deny" them "any condonation, tolerance, or boon of intercourse," as Hugh MacDiarmid once wrote of fascists, "And hold them thus beyond the human pale / To meet the vengeance there that does not fail."

No comments:

Post a Comment